Most Productive Rookie QB (Week 16)

[Will4144]

The QB with the most yards passed for 12/22/2007 and 12/23/2007. Carolina Panthers' Matt Moore will have 2/1 odds because he's already played. A touchdown will count for 100 yards. Buffalo Bills' Trent Edwards, Miami Dolphins' John Beck, Kansas City Chiefs' Tyler Thigpen.

Moore's 182 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT = 281 yards.

[justin_j36]

other Troy Smith

[justin_j36]

settle up

[Will4144]

Matt Moore - 281 "yards"
Trent Edwards - 361 "yards"
John Beck - 0 yards
Tyler Thigpen - 0 yards
Troy Smith - 299 "yards"

[justin_j36]

wow 100 pts for td and minus 1 for int what kind of bs is this
troy smith by far was much more productive
trent edwards threw 3 ints today and you call that the most productive?

[Will4144]

wow 100 pts for td and minus 1 for int what kind of bs is this
troy smith by far was much more productive
trent edwards threw 3 ints today and you call that the most productive?

I made the rules clear. Yards + TD (100 Yards) = Winner... Interceptions didn't even factor into the equation.

You bet knowing that, so don't get upset just because you put a lot of money on a 25/1 bet and lost. I'm sorry it didn't go your way, but the rules were clear.

[justin_j36]

"Moore's 182 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT = 281 yards."

How in the hell did you get this figure then? Your formula does not add up. I'm not mad about taking a gamble on a wild card bet, just wondering how that is considered the most productive QB.

[justin_j36]

?????

[Will4144]

"Moore's 182 yards, 1 TD, 1 INT = 281 yards."

How in the hell did you get this figure then? Your formula does not add up. I'm not mad about taking a gamble on a wild card bet, just wondering how that is considered the most productive QB.

I made a mistake with the total. The total should've been 282, not 281.

[Will4144]

I agree that Trent Edwards wasn't the best QB. But by the rules, he was the winner.

By the way, if it was the best QB, Matt Moore would've won. He played much better than Trent Edwards or Troy Smith.