CockyTalk

CockyTalk (http://www.cockytalk.com/index.php)
-   The Water Cooler (http://www.cockytalk.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU) (http://www.cockytalk.com/showthread.php?t=209255)

Spurticus 08-25-2014 07:08 AM

One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Vote For Your Favorite Song Between These Two:


Seed # 7: WHIP IT ~ Devo





Seed # 26: NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU ~ Sinead O'Connor




(Full Tournament Bracket)

http://www.cockytalk.com/showthread.php?t=209254

Spurticus 08-25-2014 07:30 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Odd Reasoning with my vote in this matchup.

I don't really care for either of these artists (not my personal taste in
styles I guess), but we're voting for SONGS rather than artists here.
I always loved the song NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU. Really cool
"AMBIENCE" to it.... BUT, I could never listen to it much because of
O'Connor's voice or Attitude.

Devo had a "cult" following of fans and WHIP IT became their signature
number for both the song and the video. Myself, I never cared for either.

I voted for Whip It Here.
O'Connor (for me) made a song not worth listening to even though the
song itself was good. I'm basically tossing a coin and it came up HEADS.

I really wish another artist had done NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU.
Sarah McGlacian, Jewel, or group like Celtic Woman.....someone with a much more
beautiful voice that would have made this song more appealing to me.

JerseyBird 08-25-2014 09:01 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
FWIW "Nothing Compares 2 U" was written by Prince (as you can tell by the cute abbreviations), so maybe if his version had hit the charts 8-) ?

Anyway, this is also a tossup for me as I actually like both songs, for very different reasons. Hate to have to exclude one or the other, but the nerd in me must go with Devo


TheMule 08-25-2014 09:58 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurticus (Post 4235095)
I really wish another artist had done NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU.
Sarah McGlacian, Jewel, or group like Celtic Woman.....someone with a much more
beautiful voice that would have made this song more appealing to me.

QFT

spareparts 08-25-2014 10:35 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
I voted for Whip It because as a teen, when this was released, we all thought it was about whippets

JerseyBird 08-25-2014 01:36 PM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Good a reason as any...



Wow currently 9-0 for Devo. Had I known I would have given Sinead a courtesy vote :grin:

Spurticus 08-25-2014 04:58 PM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JerseyBird (Post 4235129)
FWIW "Nothing Compares 2 U" was written by Prince (as you can tell by the cute abbreviations), so maybe if his version had hit the charts 8-) ?

Anyway, this is also a tossup for me as I actually like both songs, for very different reasons. Hate to have to exclude one or the other, but the nerd in me must go with Devo


I learned something new today !

That would explain the "Ambience" I mentioned in my post earlier and
probably the reason I liked the song itself, but never could warm up to it
because of the artist that released it. ... Even though I'm not a "BIG" fan
of Price either, the guy wrote some kick ass songs that I really liked.
The guy had a way with Lyrics and Music. I wish he had recorded and released
this song rather than O'Connor. It's a song I'd love to have liked more than
I did.

GarnetInChicago 08-25-2014 05:15 PM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Spurticus (Post 4235683)
I learned something new today !

That would explain the "Ambience" I mentioned in my post earlier and
probably the reason I liked the song itself, but never could warm up to it
because of the artist that released it. ... Even though I'm not a "BIG" fan
of Price either, the guy wrote some kick ass songs that I really liked.
The guy had a way with Lyrics and Music. I wish he had recorded and released
this song rather than O'Connor. It's a song I'd love to have liked more than
I did.

Prince performing it live with Mary J. Blige:

http://vimeo.com/51861763

and live with Rosie Gaines (I prefer this version):

http://uploadsociety.com/video_v128363

I still find Sinead's version to be very haunting, in a good way. I'd listen to that over these Prince performances.

Transmaniacon 08-26-2014 01:30 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
I'm a pretty serious Devo fan, but I'm voting for Nothing Compares 2 U because I think it is one of the best songs/performances/videos of my lifetime. Sinead's version is perfect and far better than any of Prince's versions. Although, if you ever get a chance to hear the original done by Prince's side project The Family, you are in for a treat. It's really cool and weird.

Anyway, seems like people were just rubbed the wrong way by Sinead. Too bad, because both the video for this song (and the authentic tear down her cheek during the last verse) and her performance on the recording were heavy and inspired during a time when pop music was generally lifeless. Well worth my vote.

Regalcock 08-26-2014 03:08 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Devo!!!! I guess it's the sadist in me.

JerseyBird 08-26-2014 09:02 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Transmaniacon (Post 4236116)
I'm a pretty serious Devo fan, but I'm voting for Nothing Compares 2 U because I think it is one of the best songs/performances/videos of my lifetime. Sinead's version is perfect and far better than any of Prince's versions. Although, if you ever get a chance to hear the original done by Prince's side project The Family, you are in for a treat. It's really cool and weird.

Anyway, seems like people were just rubbed the wrong way by Sinead. Too bad, because both the video for this song (and the authentic tear down her cheek during the last verse) and her performance on the recording were heavy and inspired during a time when pop music was generally lifeless. Well worth my vote.

Agreed. I think her voice is perfectly fine for the song and that the arrangement on her version is tons better than Prince's or even The Family's. Took some doing but I finally found that one:

http://mais.uol.com.br/view/zwuxgmhe...C11326?types=A

Spur's Addiction 08-26-2014 09:31 PM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
Went with Nothing Compares 2U.

While Whip it is vary catchy. Nothing Compares is a better song. And I have always kind of liked it.

Spurticus 08-29-2014 07:37 AM

Re: One Hit Wonder Tournament - (WHIP IT vs NOTHING COMPARES TO YOU)
 
WHIP IT whipped it good and moves on to the second round


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 02:22 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.7.2
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.