View Single Post
Old 05-19-2014, 10:54 AM   #15
uscGRAD04
Bowl MVP
 
uscGRAD04's Avatar
 
Male

Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Neeses
Posts: 2,476
CockyCash: 833
uscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot materialuscGRAD04 is USC mascot material
Default Re: Strange Rules and Penalties

Quote:
Originally Posted by kingoftheroost View Post
I halfway agree. If the player is serving only as the holder for a kick, then he should be allowed to have the knee down without being called down, but if his role changes (very obviously not just holding the ball), then I think he should have to pick his knee up before receiving the ball. QBs aren't allowed to receive a snap with one knee down and do anything with the ball, so why is the holder?

If they changed to the NFL rule I mentioned before about only being down by contact from another player then this would be allowed without an issue.


Edit: Which I guess it's not an issue...just strange to me.
uscGRAD04 is offline   Reply With Quote