Cowherd says Luck is a top 10 NFL QB right now...

[jcook84]

What's your top 10 right now?

Here is my list in no particular order:

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Big Ben

5. Joe Flacco

6. Matt Ryan

7. Matt Schaub

8. Alex Smith

9. Andrew Luck

10. Aaron Rodgers

Eli should probably be in there, but I can't stand the dude, and I left him off purposely. I'd rather have any of these dudes over him, any day of the week. I was having a conversation with a coworker today who is a Favre lover, I told him that I think Eli and Favre are really similar statistically...ton of yards, ton of comeback wins, ton of stupid interceptions. Personally, I'd rather have a QB that throws 25 tds and 10 ints a season and wins me 10-12 games comfortably than a guy that throws 35 td and 30 ints and has me on the edge of my seat for 8 of my 10 wins. Its just personal preference, but I'd rather have a game manager than a gun-slinger.

[BruceAlmighty]

I think you missed someone on your list...

Wears green... plays in Wisconsin.. think cheese..

[cock13]

Originally Posted by BruceAlmighty

I think you missed someone on your list...

Wears green... plays in Wisconsin.. think cheese..

He needs to discount double-check that list for his omission.

[HUGEGARNETCOCK]

Originally Posted by BruceAlmighty

I think you missed someone on your list...

Wears green... plays in Wisconsin.. think cheese..

:r otfl:

[jcook84]

Originally Posted by BruceAlmighty

I think you missed someone on your list...

Wears green... plays in Wisconsin.. think cheese..

DOH!

Yeah, he's on there...I knew for some reason finding 10 was more difficult than it should be.

With Rodgers on there I'd remove RGIII and Rivers.

[Cock Kool-Aid]

Yeah not a big fan of that list. Rodgers is top 3- not debateable. Eli Manning is simply a better QB than half the guys on that list, regardless of playing style and has the rings to prove it. You also have Luck behind some guys (Smith, Schaub, Flacco) that he should not be behind. Luck is playing for a team with slack defense and slack running game and he is basically single-handedly keeping them in games. Luck is the real deal and when Indy gets some weapons around him and he has a few more years experience, he may be the best in the league.

[jcook84]

Yeah, um...I made extra special effort to bold the text that says, "no particular order".

[2four2Gamecock]

any list without Eli in the top 5 is a joke. Love him or hate him, he is an outstanding NFL QB

[uscfreek88]

no way RG3 is top ten.....he RARELY throws down the field more than 7 yards

he also took over a team that went 6-10 with Rex Grossman and after half the season he is on pace to have same record

Rivers has been pretty bad lately too

since im critical of ur list here is mine, no order:

Manning
Manning
Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Ryan...even tho i hate him lol
Big Ben
Cutler, would have alot better numbers if he had an OL
Schaub
Smith, even tho i think he is just a game manager i have to admit he is good at what he is asked to do

[mick66]

Originally Posted by Cock Kool-Aid

Yeah not a big fan of that list. Rodgers is top 3- not debateable. Eli Manning is simply a better QB than half the guys on that list, regardless of playing style and has the rings to prove it. You also have Luck behind some guys (Smith, Schaub, Flacco) that he should not be behind. Luck is playing for a team with slack defense and slack running game and he is basically single-handedly keeping them in games. Luck is the real deal and when Indy gets some weapons around him and he has a few more years experience, he may be the best in the league.

Yeah, but he's a total mouth-breather, so that costs him. He's got to be the dumbest-looking smart person in the world.

[Cock Kool-Aid]

Originally Posted by jcook84

Yeah, um...I made extra special effort to bold the text that says, "no particular order".

woops.

[Cock Kool-Aid]

Originally Posted by uscfreek88

no way RG3 is top ten.....he RARELY throws down the field more than 7 yards

he also took over a team that went 6-10 with Rex Grossman and after half the season he is on pace to have same record

Rivers has been pretty bad lately too

since im critical of ur list here is mine, no order:

Manning
Manning
Brady
Rodgers
Brees
Ryan...even tho i hate him lol
Big Ben
Cutler, would have alot better numbers if he had an OL
Schaub
Smith, even tho i think he is just a game manager i have to admit he is good at what he is asked to do

No Luck? Luck is a better QB than Alex Smith.

[Bob the Builder]

What's your top 10 right now?

Here is my list in no particular order:

1. Peyton Manning

2. Tom Brady

3. Drew Brees

4. Big Ben

5. Joe Flacco

6. Matt Ryan

7. Matt Schaub

8. Alex Smith

9. Andrew Luck

10. Aaron Rodgers

Eli should probably be in there, but I can't stand the dude, and I left him off purposely. I'd rather have any of these dudes over him, any day of the week. I was having a conversation with a coworker today who is a Favre lover, I told him that I think Eli and Favre are really similar statistically...ton of yards, ton of comeback wins, ton of stupid interceptions. Personally, I'd rather have a QB that throws 25 tds and 10 ints a season and wins me 10-12 games comfortably than a guy that throws 35 td and 30 ints and has me on the edge of my seat for 8 of my 10 wins. Its just personal preference, but I'd rather have a game manager than a gun-slinger.

That is a terrible list. Smith and Flacco over Eli? Seriously dude? Lets name all the QB's with 2 Superbowl rings that should not be considered elite.

This is what I got
.
.
.
.
crickets

[Cigaro]

1. Rodgers
2. P. Manning
3. E. Manning
4. Brees
5. Brady
6. Ryan
7. Roethlisberger
8. Schaub
9. Cutler
10. Flacco

[uscfreek88]

Originally Posted by Cock Kool-Aid

No Luck? Luck is a better QB than Alex Smith.

you are prb right but im not putting a rookie in my top 10....but i really like Luck, he got me like 42 pts in fantasy yesterday

i would have smith at #10 if i put that list in order

[ReadR00ster]

1. Tom Brady

2. Drew Brees

3. Payton Manning

4. Aaron Rodgers

5. Jay Cutler

6. Matt Ryan

7. Eli Manning

8. Phillip Rivers

9. Andrew Luck

10. Matt Schaub

[LakeMonticelloCock]

Rodgers 10th? Seriously? The guy was Super Bowl MVP in 2010, won the league MVP last year, has the highest ever passing rating in NFL history, and is 2nd in the league in passing rating this year despite the fact his top 2 WRs(Jennings & Nelson) have been hurt.

Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL right now. He is crazy accurate and can move too.

[uscfreek88]

Originally Posted by LakeMonticelloCock

Rodgers 10th? Seriously? The guy was Super Bowl MVP in 2010, won the league MVP last year, has the highest ever passing rating in NFL history, and is 2nd in the league in passing rating this year despite the fact his top 2 WRs(Jennings & Nelson) have been hurt.

Rodgers is the best QB in the NFL right now. He is crazy accurate and can move too.

he said, in bold, no particular order

[LakeMonticelloCock]

Originally Posted by uscfreek88

he said, in bold, no particular order

Ok, my fault. I didn't read anything he said, other than the list of names.

[I Bleed Garnet]

Nm