Alex Smith on Cam Newton

[GamecockInHell]

I think that physically Cam has as much if not more talent than anyone in the NFL. Its his mental and leadership qualities that are questionable.

[cockyfreshman2014]

Originally Posted by GamecockInHell

I think that physically Cam has as much if not more talent than anyone in the NFL. Its his mental and leadership qualities that are questionable.

I think he showed something yesterday when he hurt his ankle pretty bad in a close game that in reality meant nothing. But he did everything he could to get back in the game. The sideline reporter said he didn't look away from the big screen once while he was on the trainers table. I think that says something about his leadership and caring about his teammates and team.

[803scdantes]

I can't stand Scam.

[cockyfreshman2014]

Originally Posted by 803scdantes

I can't stand Scam.

great analysis

[NCgamecock1981]

Originally Posted by GamecockInHell

I think that physically Cam has as much if not more talent than anyone in the NFL. Its his mental and leadership qualities that are questionable.

I think that's becoming an increasingly invalid argument. I really think the way he approached the game and his leadership drastically changed (for the better) after the Denver debacle.

RGIII had a great year this year. Luck had a pretty good year too. So did Cam when he was a rookie. However, defenses adjust, as Cam found out earlier this season. I'm not willing to say RGIII or Luck have a better future than Cam until I see how they do next September.

BTW RGIII should be the ROY hands down. Much higher QB rating, yards per attempt, and completion percentage than Luck and tons less INT's to boot.

[uscfreek88]

Originally Posted by I Bleed Garnet

I would too.

My comment about RG3 wrapping it up wasn't my choice, I just feel that's who's going to win it considering where he plays, what his team did, and his flashy numbers. (remember it's an AP voted award)
I also think Russell Wilson is getting disrespected by not being mentioned in the OROY debate. And that because he plays in Seattle.

Like I said, for every 2 steps back SSO takes in the Cam debate you take a step Forward

i get where you coming from, the RG3 hype has been insane...and a big reason i think that Wilson doesnt get the hype is b/c he has the best D out of all 4 of those teams hands down (Carolina, Indy, Was, and Seattle)....also beast mode to hand off too

and thanks, glad someone thinks i make some valid points lol